Skip to content
📦 Free US shipping on orders $59+ | Four Mushroom Umami Blend: FREE on $75+
📦 Free shipping on $59+ | Free Four Mushroom on $75+

Baking Spices and Extracts

Common baking spices like cinnamon, vanilla, nutmeg, and ginger are essential for great baking and flavorful desserts. Other sweet spices and fruit flavorings can be used to mix up delectable cakes, cookies, desserts, and pies. Not just for seasonal baking, this selection of essential baking spices, sugars, and pure extracts will keep you well-stocked any time you're craving sugar, or want to bake up a sweet treat. Try our multiple different varieties of cinnamon, vanilla, and cocoa.

72 Products
  • Premium Cinnamon Collection

    Indulge in the rich flavors of premium, freshly ground cinnamon sourced from around the world. Perfect for enhancing your baked goods, beverages, a...

    View full details
    View Product - $38.00
  • Black Onyx Sugar Spoon
    Black Onyx Chocolate Sugar

    Black Onyx Chocolate Sugar

    The chocolate-kissed possibilities of this black sugar are limitless. This cocoa sugar is decadent, with brownie-like flavor that will add a chocol...

    View full details
    View Product - $11.95
  • Spiced Vanilla Bean Sugar
    Spiced Vanilla Bean Sugar

    Spiced Vanilla Bean Sugar

    This spiced sugar is infused with vanilla and tastes cinnamony and sweet-spiced, with aromatic, floral notes. We took our classic coffee-favorite,...

    View full details
    View Product - $11.50
  • Salted Caramel Spice in a golden spoon, close up shot
    Jar of Salted Caramel Spice on white
    New

    Salted Caramel Spice

    The irresistible flavor of salted caramel is now a versatile salty and sweet seasoning! Salted caramel spice easily adds classic sweet and buttery ...

    View full details
    View Product - $11.50
    New
  • Cinnamon Sugar Spoon
    Cinnamon Sugar

    Cinnamon Sugar

    Our blend of cinnamon and sugar is proof that sometimes seasonings don’t need to be complex to have a big flavor impact and endless possibilities. ...

    View full details
    View Product - $7.95
  • Pure Almond Extract

    Perfect baking extract for adding real almond taste to cookies, cakes, and pastries. Infuse coffee with almond flavor. Almond extract can also be u...

    View full details
    View Product - $12.95
  • Maple Sugar Spoon
    Pure Maple Sugar

    Pure Maple Sugar

    Made by drying maple syrup that has been tapped from the sweet maple tree, and then grinding it into granules. Maple sugar seasoning is great for b...

    View full details
    View Product - $12.95
  • Dutch Cocoa Powder

    Dutch Cocoa Powder

    Rich, dark, and slightly mild. This Dutch-processed cocoa powder is perfect for brewing up a cup of hot chocolate. Great for making chocolatey bake...

    View full details
    View Product - $9.99
  • Natural Vanilla Flavor

    The perfect vanilla for bakers searching for an economical option for vanilla extract that doesn't sacrifice great vanilla flavor needed when makin...

    View full details
    View Product - $16.95
  • Pure Espresso Powder
    Pure Espresso Powder

    Pure Espresso Powder

    Your new secret ingredient for baking recipes. Pair with chocolate to create any kind of mocha treat. Perfect for brownies, tiramisu, and espresso ...

    View full details
    View Product - $8.50
  • Pure Mexican Vanilla Extract

    Use this uniquely flavored vanilla from Mexico with a cinnamon twist for baking. Add to desserts like cookies, cakes, custards, frostings, meringue...

    View full details
    View Product - $27.95
  • Ground Madagascar Cloves
    Ground Madagascar Cloves

    Ground Madagascar Cloves

    Baking with ground cloves from Madagascar adds a particular sharpness, flavor and warmth to sweeter recipes, like apple pies, cakes, and fruity des...

    View full details
    View Product - $9.95

More Information

What are the most used baking spices?

Cinnamon is probably the most commonly used baking spice. You'll probably also want to have cocoa powder, vanilla, ginger, and nutmeg on hand. Other baking spices include allspice, cloves, and other extract flavors.

How do I find the best extracts?

For the best baking extracts, it's important they're bake-proof & can withstand high temperatures for baking, so that they retain their flavor even after being in the oven.

What is baking spice?

Baking spice is a blend of cinnamon, nutmeg, allspice and ginger. To make a simple Baking Spice blend, combine 2 Tbsp cinnamon with 1 Tbsp nutmeg, 1 1/2 tsp allspice and ginger.

What spices are good in cookies?

It depends on the cookie! Definitely vanilla extract. If you want to make gingersnaps, you have to have ground ginger. For snickerdoodle cookies, you'll need cinnamon. 

What spices are used in cakes?

The most commonly used spices when making a cake are vanilla extract, cinnamon, nutmeg, allspice, cocoa powder -- or try baking with a different flavor like butterscotch, almond, maple, or lavender extract.